Motherhood Defined

I never thought I would see the day that Tyra Banks would use her show to publicly destroy hard working mothers. I found myself changing the channel several times during today's show, which she called Weekday Soccer Moms, Weekend Strippers, because I was horrified by what I was hearing. Not from the mothers on the panel, but from Tyra herself. In case you don't watch The Tyra Show or in case you missed it, let me recap.

The women on today's show were mothers who currently have careers within the sex industry. The first guest works as a dominatrix calling herself Mistress Isis, where she fulfills the fantasies of her clients (without sexual intercourse). She took on the job as a way to keep food on the table for her 3 children, after losing her job due to an injury. She enjoys her work and views it as what it is, a job. The second guest works as an exotic dancer (this term was never used during the entire show) as a way of providing for her daughter as well. Tyra deemed it necessary to spend over half the show trying to convert Mistress Isis (the dominatrix) into being a more wholesome example for her children. Apparently, being a sex worker should not be an occupation that any "good" mother would dream of doing because it "hurts" their children. This was a little hard for me to follow since Tyra kept trying to force feed Mistress Isis's daughter (who was 21 years old btw) sorrow and pain from a deep dark place in order to get her to agree that her mother's work really has had a lasting effect on her life. And the point when Tyra called on clinical psychologist Dr. Andrea Macari to diagnosis Mistress Isis as having unresolved teenage issues that have lead her to become a dominatrix is when I first changed the channel.

At what point does it become ok for motherhood to dictate a woman's entire life? Can anyone list every single characteristic of a "good" mother? Should women who work in the sex industry be denied their rights to become mothers? These are the questions that sprang to mind as I tried to wrap my head around Tyra's behavior today. She was extremely rude to Mistress Isis stating that because she chooses to work as a dominatrix that she is being selfish to her children. Only thinking about herself. Behaving like a child when she should be an example for the child that was sitting next to her. If these things were true then this mother of 3 would not be putting her hard earned cash toward keeping her children happy and healthy. When trying to state her case Tyra barreled in with insult after insult and denounced Mistress Isis's agency as a kind of acting out because she gave up her dreams to become a mother. Yes, Tyra went and played the "mother card" just because she is against sex work in general. I have seen it time and time again. She will use her show as a forum to preach to the exotic dancers or adult entertainers that she has as guests. Surprisingly, she has no idea how to really be objective when something is going down that she doesn't agree with. Isn't that sorta the job of a talk show host? To check your ego at the door and while voicing your opinions be mindful and respectful of the opinions of others? Yeah, that sure as hell didn't happen today.

The many ways in which "mother" is defined can be very interesting. People seem to think that once a woman becomes a mother that is the only hat that she can wear or the only role that she can play throughout her entire life. She is suppose to throw everything else out the window, hopes and dreams along with self, and devote every fiber of her being to her child(ren). Or at least wait until the children are all grown and she has gone gray before she can own any other identity besides "mother". We are taught by tv shows, psychologists and our own parents that these are the things that "good" mothers do. Like I said, defining what a "mother" is can be every interesting. So what do you think? Regardless to if you agree that sex work is actual work or not, if a woman is the sole provider for her children and is doing so legally, should she be condemned for the type of job she has?

This entry was posted on Monday, October 06, 2008 and is filed under . You can leave a response and follow any responses to this entry through the Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) .

6 comments

The only perfect mothers I know do not have any children...and they can fly too!

Being Jordan and Yael's mother is just one of the many hats Tameka wears. Mother is a description for a woman with children not a definition of woman. I like to say that I love my children with all that I am-and part of that is being a woman and an artist and a wife and a sister and a girlfriend and the writer of many poignant run-on sentences.

I never did like that Tyra, y'know! :)

I guess in my mind being a dominatrix is much different than stripping -yes she dresses seductively but not much different from some women we see walking down the street everyday. And hey, she isn't demeaning herself, she is in control while demeaning others. For a moment in time I considered becoming a dominatrix - it seemed like it would be fun and funny.

I was young but have always liked adventure.

Tyra has it easy because she is not a mother and clearly is conservative in many ways. I agree talk show hosts "should" be objective but it is difficult to do that especially when you want to be married and a mother as much as Tyra does. She will learn when she becomes a mother and the Nanny is taking care of her children. Judgement will be placed on her and it won't be so nice.

yeah I had no problem with the whole dominatrix thing... she kept it away from home... she was providing for her kids... I'd rather a mom be doing that than seeing kids going to school without clean clothes, a washed face, and food in their stomachs. Her kids dont know what she does... granted maybe she should hide her whips and chains a little better so they are finding that kind of stuff but her daughter that was there seemed like a flake to me. I'm sure her mom is paying her way threw college, she is doing that so her kids can have a better life and quite frankly with the daughter being grown I felt that was quite selfish of her to want her mom to stop. Now that she is out of the house and taken care of now her brothers have to struggle. Everything was blown out of proportion. THe women are NOT flaunting their careers in their child's lives so I dont see anything wrong with it. Did Tyra not know that we are in a recession. Its hard out here for a pimp like me that's doing it alone so I cant even imagine how it would be if I had a child.

You know what, until Tyra pops out a few kids and knows what it is like to be a mom, she needs to keep her mouth shut. Even when she has kids she will probably have a nanny, a full time maid and people who will take care of her kids for her while she is a working mom on her show, so she can't even compare to average everyday mom.

She should know that a mother who loves her children will stop at nothing to provide for them. I see nothing wrong with any of the ladies' career choices, who the heck am I to judge them? And who on earth is she to sit there and be judgemental!

Yeah me and Tyra don't get along. She is always being self-righteous about something. Remember her indignation with being called fat, and then a few months later she ran out and got a trainer... hmmm. Since she has no idea of how to take care of a child, and she doesn't understand the bond between child and mother how can she judge the sex industry working moms. I this very day briefly considered shaking my a** so my kids could have the luxuries they had back in April. The only thing that made me reconsider is my big ass belly and my hubby's fist waiting to black my eye...lol kinda joking here and kinda not.

ya know...the few times that i've seen her show something about the way she advised or came across or related to the guests or *something* was kind of at odds with my...being or spirit. i don't know.

it was just off and forced.